Larry Press
Communications of the ACM, May 2000, Volume 43 Issue 5.
The dream of electronic books (Ebooks) has been with us at
least since Vannevar Bush published his famous article As We May Think,
in which he speculated on a desk-sized machine which would hold ones personal
writing and library [1]. Alan Kay named
his prototype of the modern personal computer the Dynabook, and related
research has been done at prestigious centers including Xerox PARC, MIT, Bell
Labs, and Brown University. I have
speculated about Ebooks and portable devices earlier, e. g. [6, 7], but am
still reading paper books (Pbooks) because content is abundant and user
interaction is simple and subconscious.
The idea of an Ebook is appealing – a single device with an entire
library of interlinked documents, dictionary lookup, unlimited, sharable
annotation, search capability, and so forth, but the technology to date has not
been good enough to displace the Pbook.
Is it now?
For a first pass at answering that question, I looked at
two new Ebook devices, the Rocket Ebook (REB) from NuvoMedia, www.nuvomedia.com, and the Softbook (SB)
from Softbook Press, www.softbook.com. These are PC pads with flash RAM storage and
backlit, touch-sensitive monochrome screens.
The REB is 5x7.5 inches and weighs 22 ounces and the SB is 8.75 x 8.5
inches and weighs 2.9 pounds. Both are
designed solely for reading and annotating documents, and they have simple user
interfaces. The REB has three
buttons: on/off, page forward
and page backward, and the SB four buttons: a neat rocker switch for next/previous page plus menu, top-of-document,
and device-contents buttons.
If I were an early gadget adopter or traveled a lot, I
would get one of these devices. I prefer
them to a standard laptop PC for reading.
They balance well, have reasonable battery life, are small and light,
turn pages fairly thoughtlessly, boot quickly and never display Windows’ “blue
screen of death.” However, I am not
ready to purchase one today because new technology and business models are
being developed, and which will lead to improved devices and the availability
of more content. Let’s examine some of
the technology and the business considerations.
CPU speed is steadily improving, and more horsepower will
be helpful. Boot time for both the REB
and SB is under 5 seconds, but the time to open a document by loading it from
storage to RAM is noticeable. The REB
is slowest, taking about 25 seconds to load the Random House Dictionary. More subtle, but more important, is the time
it takes to “turn” a page. The REB
takes what seems to be about a second, and the SB is faster, but the time to
paint a new page is still noticeable.
If one is to become lost or absorbed in reading, the device must become
transparent, disappearing from consciousness.
Page-turn times should be imperceptible, and the page-turn gesture
thoughtless. Ebooks have an advantage
over Pbooks here -- the page toggle bar on the SB is superior to the buttons on
the REB, and both beat a Pbook.
CPU power consumption has also improved steadily during
the last decade with new chip processes, shrinking feature sizes, and lower
voltage levels. Operating systems have
also become more efficient, slowing or stopping processors to save power when
full speed was not needed. Transmeta, www.transmeta.com, may realize further
power savings with their newly announced x86-compatible CPUs targeted for
handheld and notebook devices. Transmeta’s
voltage and clock rates can be changed on the fly, and their benchmarks show
substantial power saving over x86 processors at comparable application
speeds. Of course systems use power for
displays, storage and other components as well as the CPU. The REB claims 20-40 hours between charges,
depending upon settings and usage, and the SB claims 5 hours. These are respectable figures using today’s
technology, and we can look forward to improvement.
Storage is another key element. The speed, capacity and cost of flash storage have improved
steadily over time, and it has been used in many portable devices, including
today’s Ebooks which come with between 2-32 MB. To calibrate that, I loaded 5 newspapers and magazines and four
books totaling 1,238 pages in an 8 MB SB.
This is sufficient for reading on a plane or a weekend vacation, but it
is not the lifetime library Vannevar Bush dreamt of. The capacity of rotating devices like IBM’s 340 MB, 1-inch micro
disk, www.storage.ibm.com/hardsoft/diskdrdl/micro,
is greater today, but in the long run, electronic storage would seem more
robust and power efficient.
Matchbook-size compact flash capacities are around 200 MB, flash
PC-cards hold 1.2 GB, and price falls by around 50% and capacity doubles every
year or so.
Screen technology has not improved as quickly as
electronics or storage. We have not
seen “Moore’s Law” improvements in pixel density, contrast, power consumption,
and so forth, but costs are falling.
The reading area on the REB screen is about 3 x 4.5 inches and the SB
5.9 x 7.5.[1] If after 500 years we have not converged on
a standard page size for Pbooks, there probably is no optimal screen size for
Ebooks; however, subjectively, the REB is too small for extended general
reading. On the other hand, it is fine
for more limited reading, and the small screen saves power, allows a slower
processor than the SB, and results in a smaller, lighter device. In the long run, new technology may
eliminate such tradeoffs. For example,
the LCD display may give way to products based on electronic paper, www.parc.xerox.com/dhl/projects/epaper/,
from Xerox or electronic ink, www.eink.com/index.htm,
spun off from the MIT Media Lab [8].
These hope to deliver high contrast, low power, thin, light, rugged,
displays that can be read without backlighting and in daylight, but it is too
soon to say whether they will succeed.
New software will also improve the legibility of today’s
LCD displays. Microsoft ClearType, www.microsoft.com/typography/cleartype, essentially increases screen resolution by
addressing the red, green and blue sub-pixels of an LCD display, producing
dramatically sharper text than full-pixel anti-aliasing.[2] Microsoft has many years experience in
screen readability, having commissioned the Georgia and Verdana fonts expressly
for the screen and having developed TrueType outlines and hints. ClearType researcher Bill Hill believes we
subconsciously recognize word shapes when reading Pbooks. The technology to facilitate this has been
developed over hundreds of years of subtle changes in typography and page
design, and it involves roughly 20 factors like kerning, leading, and
serifs. The higher resolution of a
ClearType display makes these possible on today’s LCD screens. ClearType is now available in some
pocket-sized machines, and they will soon ship Reader, a ClearType-based
program for reading on notebook computers.
Microsoft is committed to including ClearType in Windows 2000 when
product release cycles permit, though it will become less critical as LCD
densities increase. (LCD densities are
expected to double in the next year or two).
Network connectivity is also integral to Ebooks, and both
the REB and SB download their content.
The SB has a built-in modem, and a single click dials a server where one
orders and downloads books and periodicals.
An Ethernet interface is also available. The REB comes with a cradle that plugs into the serial port of a
PC which is used to download content from a Web site. The SB scheme is simpler for the user, and, since the content is
never on a PC, it is more secure for the publisher. With future products, one might download reading (or listening or
viewing) material to a PC, save it on PCcard or other media, and plug that into
an Ebook. Given sufficient bandwidth,
we might download entire works to Ebooks or read them directly over a wireless
network connection. Third generation
cellular standards at rates up to 2 Mb/s are now being defined, and, with the
International Telecommunications Union and the European Community taking the
lead, rollout is expected to be underway in 3 years.[3] At 2 Mb/s, one could download books and
articles on demand, clicking on any interesting reference when it occurs. Wireless LAN standards are already at 11
mb/s. If one’s home, business or school
had a high-speed connection to the Internet and a wireless LAN, reading
material could be retrieved on demand today.
Bundling and form factor options are also improving. The REB and EB are single function devices,
used only for reading. But, could we not
package more in the same or a slightly modified device? If you check a student’s backpack, you might
find a PDA, CD or MP3 music player, cell phone, books, note books, and so
forth. In a few years, these
applications will all fit in a package the size of the SB with a microphone and
speaker or a wireless headset for telephony, music, video, voice annotation,
note taking, and control.[4] A conventional laptop with a keyboard may
also be adaptable to comfortable reading with clever mechanical design. Since I consider reading a “killer app,” I
would start with a device that was optimally designed for reading, and add only
those functions which did not detract from that.
The first Pbooks were large Bibles, chained to tables in
monasteries. It took about 50 years to
evolve the form factor of the portable Pbook and much longer to settle on
typography, punctuation, and so forth.[5] There are many possible application bundles
for Ebooks, and the winner will evolve as a function of engineering and
efficiency, consumer taste, standards, and business considerations.
The manufacturers of EB,
REB and others are beginning to offer electronic versions of commercial Pbooks,
and their business model seems to be “sell them the razor then sell them the
blades.” The devices cost $200 (REB) or
$600 (SB), and electronic titles cost about the same as the print versions --
there is no major savings from the
elimination of printing, retail facilities, shipping, or inventory costs. If there are truly savings in production and
distribution, competition and market forces will ensure that some are passed on
to consumers in the future.
While commercial books and periodicals are important, most
of what we read is non commercial, and SB and REB have software that allows
users to create their own documents. I
tried the program which quickly converted some ASCII and HTML documents to the .reb
format. While this is a step in the
right direction, it is only a step.
Material prepared for one medium can seldom be automatically moved to
another. The small REB screen left HTML
tables unreadable and, of course, links did not work.
The .reb format will not become a standard. Today, nearly all electronic documents are
personal writing or relatively specialized reports and business documents in
word processing, HTML or the Adobe Portable Document Format (PDF) www.adobe.com/products/acrobat/adobepdf.html. Adobe plans to revise their Acrobat PDF reader
for Ebooks.[6] The new version will include CoolType, their
own sub-pixel font rendering technology, the ability to re-flow text to fit
varying screen sizes (while retaining the underlying page structure for
printing), and encryption. Adobe also
has their Merchant server which works in conjunction with an enhanced version
of Acrobat to provide secure payment for Ebooks, and they will support EBX, www.ebxwg.com, a proposed rights management
standard.
Microsoft will soon release Reader, www.microsoft.com/reader, a reading
program for laptop and PDA computers.
Reader will incorporate ClearType and support the Open Ebook
format. Open Ebook is a file and format
standard based on HTML and XML. It was
defined by the Open Book Initiative, http://www.openEbook.org,
of the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) with the
participation of many prominent companies, including Adobe and Microsoft. Users will be able to create Open Ebook documents using Microsoft Word,[7]
and, like Acrobat, Reader will be freely downloadable. The user interface will be designed for
effortless page turning, riffling through pages, annotation, and so forth, and
the promise of this software on millions of portables has led major publishers
to commit to electronic versions of many Pbook titles.[8]
We are in for an Adobe/Microsoft contest. The proof of the pudding will be seeing and
evaluating Reader and the new Acrobat side by side, but there will also be
business considerations. Adobe starts
with a huge installed base, and Microsoft may be looking over their shoulders
at the Government, but the financial muscle of Microsoft and the imprimatur of
NIST are not to be taken lightly.[9]
We will also see new publishing models. Authors are invited to self-publish at
Fatbrain, www.fatbrain.com/ematter/home.html. Document prices start at $2, and the author
receives a 50% royalty. Documents may
be in a number of popular formats, there is no charge for posting them, and
they may be edited by the author at any time (creating a version control
problem for readers). One finds both
well known authors like Arthur C. Clark and unknowns at Fatbrain. The emergence and acceptance of methods for
micro-payments like Compaq’s Millicent, www.millicent.com,
will enable more twists on this business model because the overhead of a credit
card transaction will be eliminated.
NetLibrary, www.netlibrary.com, sells collections of
Ebooks to libraries. For example, the
University of Texas has 6,000 books which students may browse through for 15
minutes while deciding whether or not to check them out. The business model uses the physical library
metaphor in that if an Ebook is checked out, it is unavailable to another
library patron. As with paper books,
the library can purchase multiple copies of popular titles.
Textbooks (which can
cost $100 or more) and teaching materials would seem to be a ripe Ebook
market. There is also an excellent fit
with efforts to develop devices to facilitate note taking and automate the
capture of the dialog that takes place in a classroom. For an example of this research, see the
Classroom 2000 project at Georgia Tech, www.cc.gatech.edu/fce/c2000/index.html,
with its “Zen Book” reader/note taker.
Of course, most publishing is non-commercial. Ebooks will be used for the countless
business and personal documents we and our organizations create daily, and
there are also non-commercial public forums.
Project Gutenberg, www.gutenberg.net/index.html,
is the granddaddy of all digital book libraries. It has been growing since 1971, and has nearly 3,000 books. Universities also have important electronic
publishing efforts, for example, Brown University, www.stg.brown.edu, and the University of
Virginia, etext.lib.virginia.edu,
have pioneered in Ebook and library technology and in collection building.
Scholarly publication has been on weak financial grounds
for years since journals contain specialized articles intended for small
audiences. Steven Harnad, a pioneer in
electronic peer-reviewed journals, expects researchers to become their own
e-publishers [3], and, indeed this is happening. For example, the Los Alamos Physics Archive, http://xxx.lanl.gov, contains over 100,000
self-archived papers. Also see the Open
Archives Initiative, www.openarchives.org. (One can imagine a variation of the Napster
music serving protocol, www.napster.com, for books and other material).
The Ebook has been long promised and slow to deliver, but
it may be ready to emerge now. That
will depend upon evolving technology and the quality of design and engineering
-- the technology will have to enable a transparent device and user
interface. As always, human and
organizational issues will also constrain what we end up with and when we get
it. Adoption will be slower than Ebook
proponents expect, because there are powerful, conservative social and
organizational forces holding back change and the adoption of standards. Yet, in the long run, the impact of the
Ebook may be greater than they envision.
The Ebook will be more than a substitute Pbook. What will be the social and psychological
impacts on the generations of kids who first meet Spot and Sam on Ebooks in
kindergarten?
1. Bush, Vannevar, As We May Think, The Atlantic
Monthly, July 1945, www.isg.sfu.ca/~duchier/misc/vbush/.
2. Betrisey, Claude, Blinn, James F., Bodin, Dresevic,
Hill, Bill, Hitchcock, Greg, Keely, Bert, Mitchell, Don P., Platt, John C., and
Whitted, Turner, “Displaced Filtering for Patterned Displays,” to appear,
Proceedings SID 2000 Symposium, http://research.microsoft.com/~jplatt/cleartype.
3. Harnad, Steven, Free at Last: The Future of Peer-Reviewed Journals, D-Lib
Magazine. December 1999, www.dlib.org/dlib/december99/12harnad.html.
4.
Illich, Ivan, In the Vineyard of the Text: a Commentary to
Hugh's Didascalicon, University of Chicago Press, Chicago, 1993.
5.
Platt, John C., “Optimal Filtering for Patterned
Displays,” Microsoft
Research Technical Report MSR-TR-2000-10, http://research.microsoft.com/~jplatt/cleartype.
6.
Press, Larry, "Portable Computers, Past, Present, and
Future," Communications of the ACM, March, 1992.
7.
Press, Larry, "Emerging Dynabase Tools,"
Communications of the ACM, March, 1994.
8.
Quan, Margaret, Mutant bacteria, electronic ink and paper
under development -- Offbeat technologies may hold key to displays, EE Times,
August 24, 1998, http://www.techweb.com/se/directlink.cgi?EET19980824S0058.
[1] For comparison, National Geographic Magazine is about 5.5 x 8.75 inches, the hardcover book I am reading 4.5 x 8.5, a small paperback 4.5 x 6, and an (old) Palm Pilot PDA 2.25 x 2.25.
[2] The signal processing algorithms that compute RGB intensities are derived from a model of human visual physiology and apply to any font and background colors or to an arbitrary image [2, 5].
[3] ITU, World Telecommunication Development Report, International Telecommunications Union, Geneva, 1999, http://www.itu.int/ti/publications/wtdr_99/wtdr99.htm.
[4] A headset may be necessary for high quality speech, noise cancellation, voice recognition, and so forth. That may not seem too stylish today, but styles change. People with ear plugs and portable music players were once a novelty, but they are now taken for granted.
[5] See Illich [4] for an accounting of this evolution.
[6] Glassbook, www.glassbook.com, has a well-designed reader for the current, fixed page PDF format.
[7] When a document is saved as .lit, it will be marked up as an Open Ebook documented, then encrypted and compressed for security and storage efficiency.
[8] The potential is illustrated by Dataquest’s estimate that there are 19.2 million mobile PCs, 4.8 million palm-sized and 2.9 million pad format machines today. They expect these figures to reach 33.8, 12.1 and 9.4 million in 2003.
[9] Adobe states they have shipped over 100 million copies of their Acrobat PDF reader.